Skip Navigation Links
Home
Donate
Free News via Email
Subscribe for a Friend
Send News Tip
Contact Us
Search
About Us
Is California Catholic Daily important to you?
You can help keep us online!
Advertise with us
Currently more than 150,000 visitors read CalCatholic.com
Churches Worth Driving To

* Submit Your Church *

News from the Trenches
I Couldn’t Do It...
Notes from a
Cultural Madhouse
The End...
Theology. Learn it, live it.
Speech Police! Destruction of language.
St. Joseph. Getting to know him.
CLASSIFIED ADS
San Jose & SF Bay Area - Catholic Funeral and Cemetery Preplanning: Reasonable costs and pay...(read more)
For Sale, burial plot, San Jose: Rare, very exclusive double internment burial plot. Fo...(read more)
Federal Nursing Home Reform Act: A summary of long term care laws regarding the aged and inf...(read more)
See All Classified Ads
Submit Classified Ad
CALENDAR
Covina - A Catholic Men's Conference - from Boys to Men: Presented by St. Joseph Commun...(read more)
Yorba Linda - 16th Annual Mary’s Shelter Golf Tournament: Wedn., Sept. 15, Black G...(read more)
Big Bear - Sacred Heart Retreat Camp Family Work Weekend: Fri., Sept. 3 - Sun.read more)
See All Calendar Items
Submit Calendar Item
LATEST FEEDBACK
Local Martyr I don't know about all of you, but I usually don't wear a dr... [RR - 9/2/2010 4:38:02 PM]
Anti-Catholicism of another era? Yes, Mother Mary has a special love for Muslims, as She does... [C.B. - 9/2/2010 3:48:11 PM]
How to Avoid Witchcraft or X-rated Films for Your Kids Dennis B: you wrote that if parents could afford Catholic sc... [Sawyer - 9/2/2010 3:34:56 PM]
Don Bosco relics to stop in San Francisco JLS, actually I try to stay away from political discussions ... [Mark from PA - 9/2/2010 3:29:37 PM]
“Clearly at odds with fundamental Catholic teachings” Some people idolize professors!! Yuck!!!... [Ski Ven - 9/2/2010 3:15:02 PM]

Links to Other Sites
Prior Site Archives
Article Archives

“I just don't have the energy"

Sacramento bishop asks pope to let him retire


Sacramento Bishop William K. Weigand, in failing health for many years, has asked Pope Benedict XVI for permission to retire, effective Nov. 30.

Bishop Weigand, 71, is seeking retirement four years earlier than the normal mandatory retirement age of 75. During the entire time he has served as a bishop, Weigand “has endured ill health, having been diagnosed with primary sclerosing cholangitis,” says the diocesan web site’s episcopal biography. “In April 2005, he underwent a living donor liver transplant, returning to work full time by November of 2005.”

“I'm just kind of worn out," Bishop Weigand told the Sacramento Bee. "I haven't run out of ideas. I just don't have the energy."

Pope John Paul II appointed Bishop Weigand to his current post in 1994, following 13 years as Bishop of Salt Lake City, Utah. He arrived in Sacramento in January 1994.

In 2004, Bishop Weigand publicly upbraided then-Gov. Gray Davis, telling the governor to "have the integrity" to stop receiving Communion because of his pro-abortion politics.

A year later, the bishop ordered the firing of Marie Bain, a drama teacher at Loretto High School, an all-girls Catholic prep school. Bishop Weigand took the action after a parent sent him a photograph of Bain escorting women at a Planned Parenthood clinic. In a letter to Loretto High School officials, the bishop wrote: “I am directing you, under the provisions of Code of Canon Law… to dismiss Ms. Bain with all deliberate speed."

School officials apparently balked at taking any action against Bain, but the bishop’s dismissal order made clear the reason for the firing: “Public participation in the procurement of abortions is morally inappropriate and unacceptable.” Weigand expanded his observations in an Oct. 26, 2005 letter to the faithful: "If we are to form faithful Catholic young people and provide suitable role models for such formation, teachers in our Catholic schools must themselves be witnesses to the Truth proclaimed in the Gospel, conducting themselves by word and deed in accordance with the Truths of our Faith. Their witness does not end when the school bell rings at the end of the day or the school year concludes at the beginning of summer."

In June 2005, the diocese agreed to pay $35 million to settle 33 claims of sexual abuse by priests. The bishop told the Bee that the diocese is beginning to recover from the expense, but the “hurt and pain” remain.

"He [Bishop Weigand] took us through the most serious crisis in the history of the American Catholic Church – the sexual abuse crisis – and we have come through it better than most," the Rev. James Murphy of the Cathedral of the Blessed Sacrament told the Bee. "Many of the changes he made will last well beyond his lifetime because they were institutional."

Weigand is scheduled to turn over the diocese to current coadjutor Bishop Jaime Soto at a Nov. 30 Mass in Sacramento’s more than 100-year-old Cathedral of the Blessed Sacrament, which underwent a $34 million renovation under Weigand’s leadership. As part of the ritual, Weigand will retire his coat of arms with the phrase "Feed My Lambs," which will be replaced by Bishop Soto’s coat of arms bearing the phrase “Joy and Hope.”

Weigand told the Bee he plans to spend the first six months of retirement camping out in a new trailer, writing and working on his family’s genealogy.

Bishop Soto, 51, was named coadjutor bishop in October 2007. He will become the highest-ranking Hispanic bishop in the western United States when he takes command in Sacramento. Prior being named to the Sacramento post, Soto served as Auxiliary Bishop of Orange County.


READER COMMENTS

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 12:30 AM By Central Valley
A very sad day in Sacramento to see Bishop Soto take over the lead of the diocese. God help the traditional families and priest. Soto will turn it into Orange county north.May God bless such a faithful servant Bp. Weigand. A very sad day....

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 9:01 AM By James Brady
The failure to mention his great undertaking of putting to video the then-new (1996) Catechism of the Catholic Church, with no less than the great Fr. John Corapi, is sad. Such an achievement still reverberates through the Church, and the world, should never be forgotten. It has brought so many fallen away and lax Catholics back "home" and brought many others in from the outside. What a legacy!!!

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 9:02 AM By TotaTua
Bishop Weigand - thank you for your shepherding of Sacramento. You made an incredible difference to the whole community and Northern California. You will hold a high place in my prayers for your peaceful retirement.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 10:06 AM By betty
I was interested in the drama teacher who was photographed escorting women in to a Planned Parenthood clinic, so-called.Eyebrows were raised at a Catholic school my daughter attended when a social worker (who collected her salaty from the state, not the school ) showed up in maternity clothes although she was single. She disappeared after a week of parading around in maternity clothes. We never found out how that happened because opinions were divided.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 10:15 AM By BeauZeau
Bishop Wiegand is a good and courageous man who twice, in the Gray Davis matter and the Bain matter, did exactly the right thing. I think you might say he was the most Catholic of California's bishops during his tenure, and he will be greatly missed. One certainly hopes Bishop Jaime Soto will follow his example, and not that of Cardinal Mahony or Bishop Tod Brown.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 10:30 AM By Victoria
Before Bishop Weigand departs he would do well to unburden his mind and spirit concerning all he knows about the clergy sexual abuse of children. There are still the names of perpetrators yet to be revealed. Then, when his final day arrives, the Good Bishop can stand before Our Lord as a HERO to all who have suffered so much; GOD's Children.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 10:53 AM By Central Valley
Bp. Weigand invited the Fraternity of St. Peter to the diocese, unlike any other Bishop in California allowing them to form their own parish.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 11:36 AM By DM08
Prepare for the unfriendly skies of Soto. He is a Mr. Social-justice type. I once attended a Mass where his homily was done all in text messages. He is no friend of tradition, and has decided that the immigrant apostolate will take precendence over any other activity of the diocese. Northern California has lost a wonderful bishop, and received a ominus subsitution. Bp. Soto is so bad that the only Mass I have ever actually walked out of was one being celebrated by him. Soto is "The Mahoney of the North."

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 11:49 AM By Margie
I am so grateful and thankful for all the wonderful work that our dear Bishop Weigand has done in our Diocese. It is not easy to work when one is very ill and he did a splendid job under conditions of such ill health. We have our wonderful KSMH radio station with the Bishop's Hour as a lasting legacy. Most of all Bishop Weigand was accessible. I also thank him for the tombstone that he blessed and dedicated to the unborn children in St. Mary's cemetery. He will be missed and I certainly pray for his health. May he pray for our Diocese as we move forward in uncertain times.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 12:25 PM By Trudy
DM08, OH NO!!!!! Is Soto one of those guys that trys to make the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass a form of, "ENTERTAINMENT"???????? Where do they get these people?????????????

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 1:03 PM By Kenneth M. Fisher
BeauZeau, Sorry, who do you think was responsible for Soto being made a Bishop in the first place. If you answered Mahony then Tod, go to the head of the Class! God bless, yours in Their Hearts, Kenneth M. Fisher, Founder & Chairman Concerned Roman Catholics of America, Inc. www.crcoa.com

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 1:06 PM By June V
It grieves me to see Bishop Weigand leave the Sacramento diocese. Because of him getting the FSSP into the Sacramento diocese it allowed me to return to the church after an absence of almost 40 years. God Bless him and God help the people of the diocese of Sacramento. They don't need theatrics in the Mass.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 1:38 PM By FHKJ
Bishop Weigand is in my prayers. He presided at several Masses in our parish during the last 13 years and he is obviously a holy and likeable man. It's interesting that he upbraided Gov. Gray Davis for his pro-abortion views but has said nothing about Gov. Schwarzenegger's pro-abortion and pro-gay marriage views. Is there a bit of republican favoritism here ?

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 2:23 PM By Jon
"Where do they get these people?" This brings up an important issue. And that is the process by which potential bishops are screened and recommended to Rome for appointment. I understand the Apostolic Nuncio in Washington is charged with this process, and that such explains some of the questionable appointments by JPII and B16. I mean, Mahoney to LA? Niederauer to SF?

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 3:30 PM By Pre-Boomer
Victoria: more unfounded accusations from a Church-hater. How much more of the faithful's collection money do you want?

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 4:18 PM By Victoria
Pre-Boomer, More Idolitry of the Bishops From Yet Another Devout Roman Catholic Robot. And BTW, What Are YOU Doing To Protect Children From The Horrors Of Clergy Sexual Victimization?

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 4:58 PM By E.Mae
Brace yourselves Sacramento. That Soto is no friend to tradition is an understatement. A lot of prayers, sacrifice and self-mortification is the daily agenda to survive this modern and heretical ruler.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 7:39 PM By Lupe
I almost cried when reading some of the comments about Bishops Weigand and Soto. I remember years ago when Bishop Weigand came to Sacramento. So many of us were enthusiastic, hoping that we would now have a Catholic bishop, not a modernist like Bishop Francis Quinn. It soon became apparent that Bishop Weigand was happy just letting the modernist priests tell him what to do. Yes, he hired Fr. Corapi, but when the modernists complained, out went Corapi. Yes, he gave a great sermon indicating that Gov. Davis should not receive Communion, but he did this because a local priest had refused to let Davis on his property and Bishop Weigand wanted to show that he too could make a relevant move. He practically renegged shortly thereafter. Yes, he dedicated a monument to the unborn, but his only pro-life effort is a once a year dinner. He said publicly that the Church cannot condone a homosexual lifestyle, but still allows Catholic homosexual services. As to Bishop Soto, the "insider" bishops in California are the ones who set up who will be promoted. It is clear that Soto is being groomed to take over when Cdl. Mahony retires or goes to his judgment. Watch his behind the scenes actions.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 8:57 PM By Charles O'Connell
DM08: I attended a conference at St. Mels Fair Oaks in which we were raked up 1 side & down the other by Fr. Benedict Groeschel for switching lines to receive communion from the priest rather than the extraordinary minister. This taught me a lot, as regards maintaining proper decorum in the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass. At the first Mass, Judas Iscariot - who had the Apostolic rank equivalent to Bishop - was present. Our Lord taught about this principle in the parable of the tares. I would be very cautious, DM08, about walking out on our Lord's true sacrifice made present in every Mass. The unworthiness of the ordained minister has no effect on the validity of the Sacrament.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 9:11 PM By Charles O'Connell
Lupe, I'd like to see you try to bear up under the pressure the Bishops have to tolerate. After 5 minutes you'd melt like Elphaba, the mean lady in the Wizard of Oz. We all know the charges you make, but all our Lord wants from us is to sacrifice & pray so that the Bishops will stand up to the dominant culture. It isn't up to use to judge them because we didn't appoint them - our Lord did. We weren't born God made man & didn't walk the walk of Calvary, it was the Lord. He will tell the Bishops "well done, good & faithful servant" or "throw the worthless into the outer darkness, where there will be wailing & gnashing of teeth". Don't put yourself in His place, let him do the judging & do what he requires from you. Or else you may find yourself bearing the sentence you have judged these Bishops worthy of, without having all the facts.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 9:36 PM By Dave N.
The real question is why the Pope keeps promoting such men to ever higher positions. While in the Diocese of Orange Soto wrote a letter in support of Andrew Anderson, a priest convicted in the sex abuse scandals, but his own involvement in the scandal only elicited a "mistakes were made" type apology. Soto is one of the gang along with Brown, Urell and Mahoney et. al.; no doubt he will form Sacramento into his own image. Though as for Corapi, I say good riddance; he spreads too many errors (e.g. he seems to to have a lot of trouble with Trinitarian theology.)

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 9:36 PM By Ferrer
The sins of calumny, detraction, and slander on this blog are a mortal danger for the souls of you people who are otherwise good and devout. Don't get bogged down in this wicked gossip; you will not have to answer for church appointments on judgement day. And this empty talk does nothing to rectify terrible situations present in some dioceses. You all know that a massive california quake could come any minute and take all your lives. Would you PERSONALLY be ready for death, judgement. As regards the situation the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church finds herself in, at places like California (and similar places where liberals dominate) in these last days-- focus on what each of you can do to build up our holy faith. We battle against not flesh and blood but powers and principalties of wickedness. Since the battle is spiritual; daily mass and adoration, rosary, mercy chaplet, devotion to St Michael the Archangel and "St Joseph the terror of demons." Recently I read somewhere that some devout catholic followed "the call to action" people around and unbeknownst to them she sprinkled exorcised salt in each hotel conference room suddenly every one of these meetings was mysteriously cancelled.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 10:38 PM By Pax Christi
Looks like Satan is moving his pawns right where he wants 'em. Guess he knows that putting certain prelates in "progressive" cities means they would be too lily-livered to lead the charge in sending abortion, same-sex marriage, etc. back where they came from ... hell.

Posted Tuesday, September 02, 2008 11:58 PM By Pax Christi
Looks like Satan is moving his pawns right where he wants 'em. Guess he knows that putting certain prelates in "progressive" cities means they would be too lily-livered to lead the charge in sending abortion, same-sex marriage, etc. back where they came from ... hell.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 12:31 AM By Nick
I pray that Jesus cloth the Shephard of Sacramento in Himself so that he may bear his cross patiently, have more love of God every day, and keep steadfast in the virtue of humility; and that the new Bishop, should it be God's Will, also be clothed be Jesus for the same intentions: to bear his cross patiently, have more love of God every day, and keep steadfast in the virtue of humility.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 7:30 AM By JLS
Back off, and what you become is lukewarm spit water.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 9:30 AM By Carla Rita
Charles really what diference does it make who you receive communion from if both people were sanctioned by the church itself to distribute communion

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 9:46 AM By morelovemorepower
I have yet to meet Bishop Soto but he is the man that we have been sent. Shall we lift up the arms of Moses and help him to fight? Or shall we take up a slingshot and a couple of stones and take him out? You decide, Sacramento. You decide.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 9:54 AM By Anonymous
Pax Christi, Bishop Soto prayed outside of the Sacramento downtown Planned Parenthood soon after his arrival and has been leading the charge to vote in favor of Proposition 8.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 10:51 AM By Anita
Reading these comments is so depressing. Very few people living today understand the Catholic faith. Ignorance abounds on this site. Thanks again, Vatican 2.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 11:11 AM By Anne T.
God bless Bishop Weigand and may he retire in peace.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 11:45 AM By SacCatholic
Soto is bad news everyone! Be forewarned.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 11:53 AM By SacCatholic
As for John Corapi, didn't Weigand threaten to remove his faculties? Weigand was good, an "outsider bishop" but a good step. Weigand will seem like the greatest bishop to ever walk the earth once we've had a taste of Soto. At one confirmation mass Soto celebrated he spent the whole time mocking the english language and extolling Spanish as the language of the angels. He is probably being groomed for LA, since the California bishops have decided that only immigrant Catholics matter in California. I always switch lines to recieve communion from the priest, despite what Groeschel-types say. The US Church is so weak, the clergy is so demoralized, the laity so despondent, the future so bleak. Conservative prelates love the laity when it's convienent, but will always side with their fellow clerics when push comes to shove.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 1:05 PM By T
A profound thanks to Bishop Weigand for his years of service to the people of God in Sacramento. They were blessed times. As well, a great welcome to the leadership under Bishop Soto. He is a great man with a servant's heart. I have had the opportunity to meet and work with him, and I know he will be good for the diocese. He will be active engaged in many aspects of the goings on. May God continue to bless the bishops, priests, and lay men and women of the Diocese of Sacramento

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 1:55 PM By morelovemorepower
To those of you who like to take potshots at the bishops and priests: Cut it out!

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 3:31 PM By Anthony D'Aranza
To morelovemorepower: If speaking the truth about bishops, archbishops, cardinals and, even the pope, bothers you, it is too bad. It is our obligation as Roman Catholics, to recognize and stop evil when we see it. It is OUR Church and therefore, our duty to cleanse the Living Body of Christ of those who are not worthy of our trust. I agree with the person who wrote of the seeming, "idolitry" of the hierarchy by people such as yourself to be shocking. Being a Roman Catholic is an awsome responsibility, especially in this day and age. We must be upstanding, truthful and a shining example of what Christians should be.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 4:11 PM By Wheels
I have met Bishop Weigand personally. He is an outstanding bishop. In touch with the people, faithful to the magisterium. We will miss him tremendously. God Bless you.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 5:39 PM By Dean
Anthony D'Aranza : While I agree with speaking truth when needed, we must do it in charity! That is what the Christian witness is all about! There have been some very unkind comments on here about various bishops. Why respond so angrily? We need to respond to these sorts of things by spreading truth, yes, but in doing it in context of the three evangelical virtues: Faith, hope, and CHARITY. Oh, and since when is this OUR Church? Last I checked, there was this person named Jesus that started it all...

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 5:52 PM By Dan
I don't know anything about either bishop, but I do agree with those who exhort us to offer prayers and sacrifices for them. Serious issues have been raised on this thread, and bishop Soto needs to take the concerns of his flock seriously. To the degree that he fails to do this, he fails in his calling. But our first task is to pray for him and support him as we can.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 9:27 PM By morelovemorepower
Anthony, if you know so much about how to be a good Catholic, why don't you walk right up to Bishop Soto and tell him to his face how you plan to smear his reputation? Then, you can ask him to go to confession so you can repent from your calumny.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 11:05 PM By Anthony D'Aranza
morelovemorepower, I suggest you read my post again. I have said nothing about Bishop Soto, nor have I smeared his reputation. However, you seem to know something about him that you fear I have discovered. May I say though, your name should be, "morepowermoreanger", for you seem to be a very unhappy person; and unhappy people are usually frightened people. It seems your catholic beliefs have not brought you peace. Take comfort, my friend, there is room in Heaven for us all. Why? Because Our Dear Lord Loves Us All. Quell your anger and be not afraid. Go In Peace.

Posted Wednesday, September 03, 2008 11:31 PM By Anthony D' A
Yes, Dean, I agree, we should all treat, not just the bishops, but all human beings, with charity and compassion, and in a way that we would wish to be treated. But, the truth can only be handled as the truth; and then, acted upon wherever that may lead. For instance, if crimes have been committed by an anointed member of the Catholic clergy (even if the anointed in question is a bishop), especially if the crimes involve children; then, those crimes, along with the criminal offender, must be addressed. Otherwise, we should simply empty our prisons and have anarchy in the streets. Yes, Our Lord did start it all, and how fortunate we are to have been born into it. I have heard it said many times that the church IS the, "Living Body of Christ"; and the "Faithful Are the Church". My Honor would not allow me to make up something so important. My apologies to the Editor, I did not mean to stray from the topic. I merely felt it necessary to answer Dean's questions. Thank You So Much.

Posted Thursday, September 04, 2008 1:50 PM By George Washington
Dear CalCatholic, This is a good informative article on the loss and danger to follow, but based on CalCatholic.com Mission Statement “The Christian communicator in particular has a prophetic task, a vocation: to speak out against the false gods and idols of the day — materialism, hedonism, consumerism, narrow nationalism, and the rest — holding up for all to see a body of moral truth based on human dignity and rights, the preferential option for the poor, the universal destination of goods, love of enemies, and unconditional respect for all human life from conception to natural death; and seeking the more perfect realization of the Kingdom in this world while remaining aware that, at the end of time, Jesus will restore all things and return them to the Father." In this article, like many others what is CalCatholic speaking out against? Your mission statement baffles me especially: "holding up for all to see a body of moral truth based on human dignity and rights" {Shouldn't the body of moral truth be based on God's Laws and teachings? Not man's dignity!}, and {"preferential option for the poor" What does that mean?}, and {"seeking the more perfect realization of the Kingdom in this world" This world with all its sin will never be perfect, are not souls to strive for perfection to reach the real Kingdom that of Heaven? We are to wrapped up in earthly affairs and not striving for Heaven. If we strove for Heaven, the earthly sinful affairs would diminish and fade away.} The bottom-line is your mission statement is typical convoluted Vatican II man-centered rubbish and it isn't as catholic as it could or should be. May God help CalCatholic recalibrate.

Posted Thursday, September 04, 2008 4:06 PM By MoreLoveMorePower
Interesting, Anthony, because we are to speak the truth in love. I have never met Bishop Soto. I have met Bishop Weigand and I admire his courage in taking on the nuns at Lorretto who shot the messenger. I am not angry. I am not unhappy. I am disappointed when God's people grumble in the desert as they did in the time of Moses. Should we not, as I suggest, be willing to uphold the arms of our leaders rather than taking them to task? Let God give the wheat and the weeds a chance to grow!

Posted Thursday, September 04, 2008 4:32 PM By Kenneth M. Fisher
Carla Rita, F.Y.I., the Vatican Document "On the Role of the Laity" forbids the use of "Extraordinary Ministers" except in extraordinary situations! That is why I too switch lines! Charles, I did not know that Fr. Groeschel's statements superseded Pope John Paul's statement in "On the Role of the Laity"! God bless, yours in Their Hearts, Kenneth M. Fisher, Founder & Chairman Concerned Roman Catholics of America, Inc. www.crcoa.com

Posted Thursday, September 04, 2008 4:54 PM By Andthony D' A.
Well, MorePowerMoreAnger, you might be right in the last part of your post. Those who are unworthy in our church, must be rooted out as one would root out a weed; as some of the bad bishops have been disgraced and rooted out of power. The smoke of satan must be cleansed from the RCC.

Posted Friday, September 05, 2008 5:30 AM By Fr. M.P.
The name "Extraordinary Ministers of the Eucharist" says it all. The laity are supposed to be used only in the *extraordinary* occasions, not all the time at every Mass, as has become the abuse. Yes, abuse. The extraordinary has been in practice made the norm. The 1980 document Inestimabile Donum says that "the faithful, whether religious or lay, who are authorized as extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist can distribute Communion only when there is no priest, deacon, or acolyte; when the priest is impeded by illness or advanced age; or when the number of the faithful going to Communion is so large as to make the celebration of Mass excessively long." The latter phrase has been interpreted in general that one second extra time is too long, therefore armies of EMOTE are always present. Feel free to switch lines to the priest.

Posted Friday, September 05, 2008 12:19 PM By Ed
All this talk of what the Bishop will do when takes over is a moot point the minute he became coadjutor he was in a position to influence everthing in the diocese. It is sad to see a bishop go, however, the laity already know what to expect when Bishop Soto comes in. There has been a year of Soto already though not with him in full control. With Mahony due for retirement, I think it would best for all California Catholics to start sending letters to Rome via the Nuncio detailing the errors of Mahony and Soto. I believe that if enough priests and laity reject Soto -- there will be a change. It happened in Chicago 8 years ago, although with a pastor. Cardinal George was forced to appoint a new pastor...

Posted Friday, September 05, 2008 5:52 PM By Doug
Fr. M.P. I enjoy most of your comments especially when you are citing ancient scripture and encyclicals. After all the abuses in the last 40 years you have seen to the Holy Sacraments of the Roman Catholic Church, the criminal pedophile priests and the bishops that protected them, I ask what keeps you loyal to the Vatican II church? May God bless you on His Holy Way. Please pray for me a sinner.

Posted Friday, September 05, 2008 8:32 PM By JLS
Doug, the key is your desire to do the will of God. One iota of an act of faith will provide all the power to resist sin and do good. Knowing stuff, no matter how sublime, will not do it. Adam and Eve knew everything God wanted them to know, and yet chose to sin. Countless millions of souls who have never known much, yet exercised faith, have led holy lives. It is not what you know, but Who you know. Jesus teaches simply to open your heart to God. Study the Beattitudes until you are doing them, or at least one of them ... not saying to memorize them, or to "know" them, but to do them; choose a Beattitude and make it part of your life.

Posted Friday, September 05, 2008 8:37 PM By JLS
George Washington, your post is a perfect example of why we have a pope to interpret things we do not understand. Take out your painful wooden false teeth, get rid of the doctors who are bleeding you to death, and read the mission statement with eyes of faith. It is not a legal statement to be arbitrated over by the domain of law, but a religious statement which is greater than law. Remember that Jesus fulfills the Law of God, and He is even more than divine Law. This is why we have recourse to that which is greater than law, namely to the Law Giver Himself, through Jesus Christ, true God and true man, sinless, Who takes all sin and relieves the penitants of the burden of paying the price.

Posted Saturday, September 06, 2008 7:24 PM By Sarah
Well, usually the incoming bishop in a diocese is cut from the same cloth as the outgoing bishop. Still I do want to keep an open mind. It would be helpful if Bishop Soto would hold a town hall meeting of sorts so that the people he is to lead can express their hopes, wants, needs and fears. I don't know if anything such as that has ever been done before, but what a step forward it would be.

Posted Sunday, September 07, 2008 3:32 AM By INRI
Having known little of Bishop Soto before reading this blog, I am concerned now for the future of our Diocese under him. Yet, I would also like to give him the benefit of the doubt and wait to see what he actually does as Bishop. I suspect that something akin to Affirmative Action may be at work in the American Catholic Church leading to the promotion of less qualified clergy over more qualified clergy for the sake of "diversity." However, I have no evidence of this as yet. It is just a hunch. Bishop Weigand disappointed me in only one way: No Diocese-wide prohibition against same-sex couples sending their kids to Catholic schools. The current policy is that this may be decided on a school-by-school, case-by-case basis. Otherwise, I have been pleased with Bishop Weigand and will miss him.

Posted Sunday, September 07, 2008 6:01 PM By Fr. M.P.
Doug, because the "Vatican II Church" IS the Church, that's why. I know how to separate bad members of the Church from the teachings of the Church. After all, even Jesus put up with Judas, giving us the ultimate example of bad priests and prelates. Most people make the wrong assumption saying that because the faith went down after Vatican II, then Vatican II must be the cause. Rather the modernists already in the Church for decades (read St. Pope Pius X) used that time of the council as the smoke screen to "come out." If you've really read Vatican II documents, you will see that they are not in contradiction with the Church. Those who say they do contradict interpret the documents in their lens looking to prove the "church is wrong" and "they are right" for interpreting Tradition. Rather it is the Church who interprets Tradition, not persons or even groups like SSPX. There are many Judases today because this is the time of great apostasy.

Posted Monday, September 08, 2008 12:52 PM By Gregorian
When will the Pope realize that if he wants to revitalize the church, he's going to have to pick better Bishops. God help us.

Posted Friday, December 05, 2008 12:54 PM By John S. Jarstad, M.D
I am not a Catholic but was so very impressed with Bishop Wiegand's defense of the LDS church on the Prop 8 issue. When it seemed that the LDS Church was going to have to go it alone, Bishop Wiegand's heroic statement did more to create bridges of faith between our two churches than anyone has done in a long time. I recently attended a Gladys Knight concert and she stated, "there is a war going on and all people of faith need to band together," I couldn't agree more. May the Lord bless Bishop Weigand with the peace that passes all understanding and bless all of you at this Christmas time of year. J.Jarstad, M.D. Seattle

Posted Friday, December 05, 2008 2:51 PM By Almond Milk
John S. Jarstad, M.D thank you. God bless you too and Merry Christmas....Happy advent season.

Posted Friday, December 05, 2008 9:09 PM By Mark from PA
To INRI, when I was in Catholic school, non-Catholic children were allowed to attend and this is still the case. Many Catholic schools allow non-Catholic children to attend. If they let non-Catholic kids in I don't think they can discriminate against Catholic children of same-sex couples. Do you think these children should be discriminated against?

Posted Saturday, December 06, 2008 12:03 AM By Eileen
Mark from PA, You asked INRI if he thought that children of same sex couples should be discriminated against? Children of same sex couples were already discriminated against when they were placed in those circumstances to begin with. That is disappointing that Bishop Weigand did not set forth a policy of uniformity. The Catholic Church is the Universal Church not school to school based. Pope Benedict XVI said the following, "Allowing children to be adopted by same sex unions would actually mean doing violence to these children, in the sense that the condition of their dependency would be used to place them in an environment that is not conducive to their full human development." Sending children of same sex couples to Catholic schools has been and is a goal of the homosexual agenda. The result is that the other children are confused as well as scandalized when this union is portrayed as just another acceptable lifestyle. This sends mixed messages to children whose innocence should be protected. Since many of these children have been baptized this presents a difficult dilemma for the innocent children who were adopted. What an assault on their development and peace to go to school and learn that their caretakers have rejected Church Teaching and could possibly be sent to hell if they do not see how much this has offended God. The hope would be that through the private instruction of the children, the caretakers would also agree to attend with the openness to reconcile their actions to follow Church Teaching. Then the caretakers souls and the children's souls would be given the best opportunity in these circumstances. Many activists are not interested in reconciling their actions though. They want the Church to approve of their sinful lifestyle. Allowing children of same sex couples to attend Catholic Schools is spiritually counter-productive. The baptized children do have a right to learn the true faith not the politically correct faith. The children always suffer.

Posted Saturday, December 06, 2008 6:38 AM By Grisha
Mark From PA and INRI ~ My God! How in the world could anyone deny a child, especially a baptized child, a Catholic; school education based on the child's parents being gay? INRI -Why, why would you advocate such a thing? I really want to know!

Post your Comment
Name:
Email: (Optional: Will not display)
Comment:
 
Comments are limited to 1500 characters, and cannot contain offensive or libelous language. For security, comments cannot contain html tags, including < and > symbols - and NO URLS or LINKS. Comments will appear after they have been approved by the editor. Inclusion of your email address is optional so the editor may contact you.



Calcatholic Mobile
Optimized for your
mobile device











Visitors since January 1st, 2009:
javascript hit counter

website created by Vigil Studios © 2006 -  www.vigilstudios.com